Call Today (386) 752-0006

About Us

Our agency is a locally owned agency, providing auto, boat, commercial/bonds, home, life and workers compensation insurance. Trevor Hickman Insurance was created with our valued customers in mind, knowing customers seek an agency with the ability to provide clear explanation of coverage and price, we shop the coverage on your behalf.

With this principal in mind, we are able to understand each customer’s specific need and design a product best suited to those needs, at the lowest possible cost.

Free Car Insurance Quotes in Lake City

Trevor Hickman Insurance is here to serve you!

Our agents have a combined 130 years of experience in the property and casualty business, and we utilize a host of carriers to assist us in meeting our customers objectives. Although we are locally owned, we are affiliated with Allied, Progressive, Safeco, Travelers, Chubb – just to name a few.

Again, our focus will always be placing the customer first and providing quality service, products and price to you, our valued customer.

As an Independent Insurance agency, we  are committed to treating you as a person, not a policy. This commitment means:

  • Explain the coverages and options available to you to find the insurance coverages, you your family or your business need. We can then use our access to multiple companies to deliver those coverages.
  • We will guide you through the claims process for a prompt and fair resolution of your claim.
  • We will help solve any problems related to your policy and or coverage through our agency, at your request.
  • We will return your phone calls and emails promptly and respond to your requests in a timely manner.
  • We will use our experience and multiple company relationships to customize your coverage as needed.
  • We are dedicated to our continuing education to be more knowledgeable in serving you.
  • We conduct our business in an ethical manner, and treat you with respect and courtesy.

We pledge this to you, our clients, and ask that you let us know if we fail to meet our commitment, so we may take corrective action.

Meet Our Team

Trevor Hickman


Trevor Hickman has been a resident of Columbia County since 1966. He is a graduate of Columbia High School and Lake City Community College, now Florida Gateway College. Trevor has been married to his wife, Tracy, for more than 25 years and has three children, Kyle, Kelsey, and Katelynn. Trevor has been a licensed insurance agent since 1991. He purchased the agency effective January 1, 2011, after serving as the Managing Agent for over 17 years.

Trevor served as the 1999 Chamber of Commerce President and chaired several Chamber committees. Trevor also served for many years on the Happy House Board and was a member of the founding Crime Stoppers Board of Columbia County. He has served as a volunteer for the United Way, where he and his wife Tracy are members of the Challengers Group. Trevor is a member of the Rotary Club of Lake City. He has coached youth sports in Columbia County for many years, including soccer, baseball, football, and basketball.

Debbie Burns-Luke

Client Account Advisor

Debbie joined Trevor Hickman Insurance Agency in October 2002 as an office administrator and customer service representative. She obtained her insurance license in 2003, and now has over 20 years experience with customer service in the insurance industry. Debbie became a personal account adviser in June 2009 with our agency. Debbie enjoys providing solutions for our clients’ insurance needs. Debbie has lived in Lake City since 1971 and graduated from the Columbia High School in 1988. She then attended Lake City Community College, now Florida Gateway College, focusing on business administration.

Beverly Taylor

Customer Service

Beverly joined Trevor Hickman Insurance in July of 2009 as an office administrator/customer service representative. She has 35 years experience in customer service with 25 of those years dedicated to the insurance industry.

Beverly has a strong belief that the best advertising for any company is having satisfied customers. She loves helping people and makes every effort to make sure that clients are happy with the service they receive from the agency.

Beverly spends her spare time with her four girls, their husbands and her grandson. They all love Disney and take every opportunity to escape and enjoy the “magic”.

Marie Skinner

Personal Lines Agent

Marie Skinner, Personal Lines Agent, has over 20 years of insurance experience. She started her insurance career in the mid-1980s selling auto insurance as a customer service representative. Marie earned her general lines license in 1992 and her life and health license in 1995. She specializes in auto, home, flood and umbrella insurance. Marie joined Trevor Hickman in 2006 as a personal lines advisor, she has two grown children and three grandchildren.

Crystal Cantrell

Business Account Advisor

Crystal Cantrell, Business Account Advisor, recently joined our staff in February 2013 bringing with her over 26 years of insurance experience. She started her insurance career in May 1987 and obtained her agent’s license in August 1988. Her knowledge expands to all aspects of the insurance industry and is currently helping our commercial clients with all their insurance needs. Inher leisure time she loves to bake, read, cross stitch and spend time with her family.

Trevor Hickman Insurance in Lake City

designed by iwebresults